Bankruptcy Questions Answered

Proposed Bill Would Change Role of Student Loans in Bankruptcy

Student loans have become infamous for rarely being discharged in bankruptcy. However, before 2005, only government-backed student loans were protected—private student loans could be forgiven in bankruptcy.

The Chicago Defender reported that several U.S. lawmakers have proposed a piece of legislation that would allow bankruptcy courts to once again discharge student loans issued by private lenders.

The legislation, which is still in its earliest stages, would address what its sponsors (including Rep. Danny K. Davis, Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, Sen. Dick Durbin, Rep. Steve Cohen and Sen. Al Franken) see as an unrealistic burden of debt many students have upon graduation.

Indeed, the statistics cited by the Defender and a press release from Senator Durbin’s office are eye opening:

• Until the Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act (BAPCPA) took effect in 2005, private student loans were treated like other loans in bankruptcy; now, they can only be discharged if a filer can show "undue hardship."
• Congress recently ended a $6 billion subsidy to private student lenders, thus eliminating one advantage they had over other lenders. This student lending reform was signed into law as part of the health care reform legislation. The sponsoring legislators argue that the restoration of dischargeability will further level the playing fields.
• Private student loans have increased in both popularity and cost in recent years, some coming with interest rates at and above 15 percent.

If the new bill becomes law, its sponsors contend, it will give students wishing to pursue higher education a certain peace of mind, as they will have the option of discharging the associated debts should they encounter unexpected financial hardship.

The Current Law

As it stands now, BAPCPA permits individuals who file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy protection to receive a full discharge of many unsecured debts (that is, filers are excused from paying these debts); however, some debts cannot be discharged in a Chapter 7 filing. These include:

• Spousal support (alimony)
• Child support
• Student loans
• Most tax debt

Supporters of the new bill apparently believe that student loans don't fall under the same category as the other non-dischargeable debts, as they do not contribute directly to someone's wellbeing.

But the bill will likely have obstacles to overcome in Congress. Opponents are likely to point out that making private student loans dischargeable in bankruptcy decreases lenders' security when issuing these loans and could lead to increased interest rates and fees to compensate for potential lost income.

Additional Resources

Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act (BAPCPA) (PDF)